It’s never going to end. It will never, ever end:
From Day 1 of the Spygate saga in September, the controversy over New England’s illicit videotaping practices has centered on the Patriots’ efforts to steal their opponents’ defensive signals. But the tapes delivered via FedEx to NFL headquarters in New York on Thursday morning also include evidence of an effort by New England to steal offensive signals, which would broaden the extent of the team’s surveillance operation.
It would have to broaden it into some other sport, as Pro Football Talk explains:
[T]here’s no such thing as “offensive signals.” At least there aren’t “offensive signals” in the same sense that there are (or, given the coming use of radio receivers for defensive players, were) “defensive signals.” On defense, the coaches signal in the play to the players on the field. On offense, the play is called into the quarterback via the radio in his helmet.
Presumably, the tape created by Walsh shows the hand signals made by offensive coaches to alert the players on the field, and on the sidelines, to the personnel groupings that would be used, such as two running backs, one tight end, and two wideouts, or two tight ends, one running back, and two receivers.
Here’s how one source explained the process to us: “A play ends and the offensive coaching staff yells out on the sideline and simultaneously puts up a hand signal. Let’s say they want ‘regular’ personnel, which is two backs, two receivers and one tight end. The signal would be something like putting one finger in the air. The coach holds it up, but generally so do the players that are running on the field. The whole world sees it.”
And one group of folks who see it are the advance scouts from other teams who are attending the game for the purposes of, among other things, figuring out the number of fingers that are put in the air for each type of offensive grouping. It’s a simple process, and it’s a code that doesn’t require much effort to crack.
That’s in sharp contrast to the signals used by defensive coaches to call in defensive plays, which entails a level of intricacy that would require Rain Man-style abilities to decipher on the fly. [...]
So there’s really nothing to it. And, as others have pointed out, the rule that the Pats broke relates to taping generally, not to the taping of offensive or defensive signals. Thus, the presence of one tape with “offensive signals” doesn’t constitute the kind of new evidence that will land the team or coach Bill Belichick in a fresh vat of boiling water.
We know that plenty of folks who don’t like the Patriots and/or media figures who want to see a compelling story fill the slow months because now and July hope that some previously undisclosed proof of cheating will emerge. If it does, it most likely won’t come from the Walsh tape with the “offensive signals.”
Maybe they are tapes of coaches “flipping the bird”? In any case, I eagerly await the existance of game film to be held up as evidence that the Patriots are stealing their opponents’ uniform designs, or their secret “snap-the-ball-to-start-the-play” signal, or perhaps their super-top-secret plan to put 11 players on the field. Isn’t it time for Pacman Jones to beat up somebody in a strip club already? The vultures are getting stupid.
May 12, 2008 at 12:45 pm
But, on the other hand, football is nothing but rugby for sissies.
May 12, 2008 at 2:04 pm
Poor Patriots fans. First their super-duper team LOSES TO THE GIANTS (capitalization to remind said fans of that HILARIOUS fact), and now they have to resort to spy-gate denial, which is, like, one step up from [censored due to Godwin's law].
At least there was an earth quake and a cyclone, and there are politician’s bowling scores to talk about, so the story isn’t all over the news channels 24/7.
May 12, 2008 at 2:16 pm
Sweet, sweet karma. I’m glad we’re now able to account for Belichick’s rise from the Dawg Pound to the heights of annoying glory. It seems like those in sports who are mean to the press (see: Barry Bonds, Belichick), always take a huge tumble.
Cartoons here: http://spinachflame.wordpress.com/
May 12, 2008 at 2:23 pm
Yes, it really, really sucks how going 18-1 and rewriting the record book might end up being our fifth or sixth best season of the decade. I don’t know how I manage some days.
May 12, 2008 at 3:14 pm
Except that Foxboro is notorious because opposing QBs suddenly develop radio problems and sometimes have to rely on hand signals to get the play from the sidelines.
May 12, 2008 at 4:33 pm
This will end only when Bill Belichick and the Patriots are entombed beneath a veritable hail of asterisks.
May 12, 2008 at 4:35 pm
PS I thought you all might enjoy this hard-hitting column.
May 12, 2008 at 5:25 pm
If the Patriots are so great, how come the Packers beat them in the Super Bowl? They lost then because the cheating Belichek wasn’t there to cheat. This will not end because cheating is not a respectable was of winning games. I’m actually glad that the Patriot’s winning this decade is now forever tainted. Ha. I say. Ha.
May 12, 2008 at 5:37 pm
What’s really funny is that all of the folks screaming for Belichicks head are going to be crying louder come September when the season starts, and the Pats begin chewing up their favorite teams.
They went 18-1 last year, with a tough schedule (hats off to the Gints), and this season is comparatively easier. Get ready boys and girls.
Watching Arlen Specter trying to scrape up political points in the year of GOP conflagration should be fun. Never mind what Parcells or Jimmy Johnson think, what does Arlen have to say?
May 12, 2008 at 5:43 pm
Except that, unless Foxborough is notorious for having coaches lose their voices and/or QB’s wristbands exploding into flames, teams still don’t call offensive plays by hand signal. And, in the parallel dimension where they do, and where Tony Romo isn’t a choke artist, taping such signals would still offer no in-game advantage; see: taping defensive signals, shit we already knew.
Because it was 1996.
May 12, 2008 at 6:12 pm
I think the “OFF” tape was from 2001 or something, and I don’t know when radios became standard for certain aspects of playcalling. I really wish the Patriots had destroyed the Giants.
May 12, 2008 at 7:27 pm
I heard there was an election this year. Any news about that?
May 12, 2008 at 7:33 pm
No. The Patriots did something wrong and rightly, they were heavily fined. They are a .500 Super Bowl team and their choke in the last Super Bowl makes Scott Norwood look heroic.
Nobody gives a shit about regular season records, (even with NE’s payroll and fun interpretation of the rules everyone agreed to obey) or even going to four consecutive SBs, (even in a suck early 90s AFC, I know, I checked.)
Patriots suck my ass. Sniff the Bison.
May 12, 2008 at 7:48 pm
Oh and what’s with the decade discrimination?
If events that happened more recently, (The pats beat the Carolina Panthers..barely) are more important then events that happened in the relatively more recent past, (The NFC Central clogs up the big dig with fecal matter) but not the events that happened somewhere in the middle, (Colts win SB, beat someone? on the way), then why the fuck do I have to keep celebrating these stupid holidays?
If only I could just celebrate last Tuesday but the giant dump that the Manning brothers took on Boston knocked out space time as we knew it.
May 13, 2008 at 5:34 am
I would like to second the wise remarks of Herr Dr Professor.
And if any of you are in Frankfurt/M, Germany on Saturday the 24th, why not come watch the 1. Bundesliga rugby final at SC 1880. It’s ‘80 against hated rivals RG Heidelberg and there’s not a bad seat in the stadium (in large part because there are no seats in the stadium). The quality of play should be good, and will in any case not be worse than the performance in the recent 6 Nations tournament of countries in the British Isles that are not called “Wales”. Also, I understand that beer may be available; kickoff at 3.
May 13, 2008 at 5:35 am
Accustom yourself to this bullshit, O Editors. It will not end this year, or the next. The Pats being bad-ass will be attributed to the stealing of offensive signals, and their getting stomped to its lack. Such is the force of myth.
May 13, 2008 at 5:47 am
Football? 10s of thousands dead in Myanmar, a war still going on, a recession in which thousands are losing their homes, a presidential election in progress, and we’re talking about football? Where are your priorities? It’s baseball season for Chrissakes!
May 13, 2008 at 10:09 am
And Matt Walsh has now provided the NFL with NOTHING.
God, this is awesome. And the best part is the Patriots are still Super Bowl contenders next year, and Donovon McNabb will be on IR by late August.
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL. SUCK IT.
May 13, 2008 at 1:27 pm
New England Football fan = oxymoron.
Actually, New England Football FANS = morons.
Did I mention: Giants 17, Pats 14? But at least you still have the trademark on the phrase, “18-0.”
May 13, 2008 at 8:45 pm
What’s wrong with 2996? Elitist.
May 13, 2008 at 8:45 pm
That should be 1996 – I didn’t eat enough cheese today.
May 14, 2008 at 2:15 pm
Eli Manning? Really? That’ll never be lived down, sorry, The Editors.