Dick Cavett, like most sentient, hearing-enabled human beings with at least a passing familiarity with English any spoken language in the history of the known universe, hears Sarah Palin and wonders what sonic virus is breaking down his brain tissue with such a grating relentlessness. Camille Paglia, on the other hand, hears…starbursts. Starbursts and jazz:
So she doesn’t speak the King’s English — big whoop!…She uses language with the jumps, breaks and rippling momentum of a be-bop saxophonist.
Starbursts, jazz, beat poetry, rock ’n’ roll and…hip hop?:
However, Cavett’s piece on Sarah Palin was insufferably supercilious. With dripping disdain, he sniffed at her “frayed syntax, bungled grammar and run-on sentences.” He called her “the serial syntax-killer from Wasilla High,” “one who seems to have no first language.” …
I was so outraged when I read Cavett’s column that I felt like taking to the air like a Valkyrie and dropping on him at his ocean retreat in Montauk in the chichi Hamptons [ed note: Montauk is not in the Hamptons. Montauk is in...Montauk oddly enough. I know because I'm ChiChi like Rodriguez and I don't fact check myself. But maybe I was right all along?]. How can it be that so many highly educated Americans have so little historical and cultural consciousness that they identify their own native patois as an eternal mark of intelligence, talent and political aptitude?
In sonorous real life, Cavett’s slow, measured, self-interrupting and clause-ridden syntax is 50 years out of date. Guess what: There has been a revolution in English — registered in the 1950s in the street slang, colloquial locutions and assertive rhythms of both Beat poetry and rock ‘n’ roll and now spread far and wide on the Web in the standard jazziness of blogspeak. Does Cavett really mean to offer himself as a linguistic gatekeeper for political achievers in this country? [...]
Yes, that is the lordly Yale that formed Dick Cavett’s linguistic and cultural assumptions and that has alarmingly resurfaced in the contempt that he showed for the self-made Sarah Palin in “The Wild Wordsmith of Wasilla.” I am very sorry that he, and so many other members of the educational elite, cannot take pleasure as I do in the quick, sometimes jagged, but always exuberant way that Palin speaks — which is closer to street rapping than to the smug bourgeois cadences of the affluent professional class.
First of all, anyone looking to lecture another about being out of touch with what the hep young cats are doing these days (meaning the 1950′s on) should avoid using terms like “street rapping” and “jazziness of blogspeak” whenever possible.
There is zero jazzy about blogspeak. And what the fuck is street rapping? As opposed to…say, suburban rapping? And, really, the grimy streets of South Central Wasilla?
Watching Paglia try to cop a “with-it” pose is like watching that too-eager aunt at the family function stiffly raising the roof and pushing out a cabbage patch on the dance floor and looking around at the young folk with an in-the-know twinkle in her eye. It doesn’t impress as much as induce a feeling of embarrassment for the dancer herself. Unlike someone’s well-meaning aunt, though, Paglia gets paid do make a fool of herself aping the latest trends – if on a larger stage.
Anyway, here’s some of MC Mooseknuckle’s flow:
Sitting here in these chairs
that I’m going to be proposing
but in working with these governors
who again on the front lines
are forced to and it’s our privileged obligation
to find solutions to the challenges facing our own states
every day being held accountable
not being just one of many
just casting votes or voting present every once in a while
we don’t get away with that
we have to balance budgets
and we’re dealing with multibillion dollar budgets
and tens of thousands of employees in our organizations
Even at his most dusted out, ODB made more sense than that shit. Cause, you know, all street rap is is just a string of meaningless gibberish meant to conceal the fact that the street rapper doesn’t know shit about what he/she is talking about - or the world in general.
And Paglia chides Cavett and liberal critics of Palin for being condescending while Paglia uses be-bop and hip hop as synonyms for uneducated and stupid.
Make. Her. Go. Away.
Elswhere: IOZ looks at another graf from the same Paglia offering:
The slaughter of the Holtzbergs and other Jews at Chabad House should be a wake-up call to Western liberals who believe that jihadism can be defeated through reason and happy talk. Only other Muslims can launch the stringent internal reform necessary to stomp this barbaric extremism out. But the events in Mumbai confirmed my opinion about the looming problem of a nuclear Iran: While I oppose all American military operations and bases in the Mideast, I continue to believe that Israel, whose security is directly threatened, has every right to take preemptive military action against Iran.
So. The killing of Jews in an Indian City by Islamic Radicals from somewhere around Punjab or Kashmir “confirmed [her] opinion” about a nuclear Iran and the rightness of Israel launching a bombing campaign? Yeah, the divorce and remarriage of French President Sarkozy confirmed my opinion about the necessity of banning gay marriage in California. What? Why?
Adding: Since “only other Muslims can launch the stringent internal reform necessary to stomp this barbaric extremism out” (which is so not a liberal position), therefore we must bomb Muslims until they stomp this barbaric extremism out. That’s the only ways.
December 11, 2008 at 10:14 am
This only echoes the basic point that you made, but why does Salon pay this woman to spout this gibberish?
December 11, 2008 at 10:24 am
Family Circus is more relevant to modern day America than Paglia..and more insightful too.
December 11, 2008 at 10:37 am
You’re right about The Aunt Who Would Be With-It.
Or, to put it another way, Paglia defending Palin is a missionary praying for the soul of the cannibal who’s par-boiling him in the cauldron.
December 11, 2008 at 11:04 am
While Paglia is an insufferable idiot in almost all the ways you say, Montauk is in fact in the Hamptons — in East Hampton, to be exact.
December 11, 2008 at 11:12 am
Summanabitch, you’re right LP.
It’s just that they’re so often referred to separately and distinctly.
Serves me right for snarking without fact checking my own ass.
December 11, 2008 at 11:17 am
Yo man, FUCK de Hamptons, esse’! Beeyutch be talkin’ like a foo’ cuz she is one, straight up. Bof dem dog-holes. Word.
December 11, 2008 at 11:22 am
Sounds like Camille is getting disenchanted with Madonna (I mean, she didn’t even mention her once, which is remarkable), and is looking for another horse to hitch her creaking wagon to. Be-bop saxophonist and street-rapping? I can hear a good approximation of Wasilla-speak up in the hills of California, and it’s like calling the Beverly Hillbillies wordsmiths. Be-bop and street-rapping my ass. I don’t think Camille has a good handle on either of those. Paglia is so desperate to be relevant, so transparent, and such a suckup that it’s a comedy in slow motion to watch her life pass. I think that we put a black man in the presidency has given her the vapors and she just can’t handle it. My prediction is that she’ll creepily attach herself to Palin like a remora to a shark. A remora who spouts word salad once a week.
December 11, 2008 at 11:27 am
OTOH, just like with Madonna, maybe La Pagliacca just has crazed lesbo fantasies about Sister Sarah. And as for her faux Fargo patois, it is in fact way older than Cavett’s Nebraska midwestern speak. Same as Johnny Carson’s. Who w/o trying was cooler than the whole rat-pack combined.
But of course, that’s the way it works.
December 11, 2008 at 11:29 am
Beat poetry and rock ‘n’ roll and now spread far and wide on the Web in the standard jazziness of blogspeak.
IMO — LOLzers!!11! Can I has Tenyur Now?
December 11, 2008 at 11:58 am
I learned an interesting thing about the remora: the job is not that secure. At the Monterey Bay Aquarium, they noticed that the number of remora around a particular shark dwindled to nothing when there were a finite number of remora in the tank.
December 11, 2008 at 12:32 pm
I don’t think human behavior can be attributed to global warming, also.
December 11, 2008 at 1:08 pm
“The slaughter of the Holtzbergs and other Jews at Chabad House should be a wake-up call to Western liberals who believe that jihadism can be defeated through reason and happy talk.”
This is worthy of Rush Limbaugh. “Western liberals” believe–I know a couple–not that “reason and happy talk” will do it, nor that BushCo “Shock ‘n’ Awe” ™ in the WWII model will, either.
Really, Camille. If you want to join Dennis Miller and Newt Gingrich as one of the “hipsters” of the right, just SAY so.
December 11, 2008 at 1:17 pm
Or, alt., don’t, and remain the Rusty Warren/Moms Mabley of the left. It’s a living!
December 11, 2008 at 1:26 pm
If you put Palin’s flow over some RZA beats, I’d listen to it.
December 11, 2008 at 1:37 pm
Well, Paglia is one relentless remora, and apparently sticks very well, thus not getting eaten. Who else but the silly, inconsistent Salon would give her editorial space? She belongs in NRO, or better still LGF.
December 11, 2008 at 1:42 pm
If you put Palin’s flow over some RZA beats, I’d listen to it.
Yeah, but I’d listen to fran drescher laughing in a loop if RZA hooked it up…
December 11, 2008 at 1:43 pm
closer to street rapping than to the smug bourgeois cadences of the affluent professional class
While “street rapping” may remain a closed book to her, “the smug bourgeois cadences of the affluent professional class” she knows like her own native patois.
December 11, 2008 at 2:06 pm
Earth people…
New York and California
Earth People…
I was born on Jupiter
December 11, 2008 at 3:08 pm
Mail order for Paglia, Camille:
3 Items
Item #1) Reprinted salon.com article, dated 12/10.
Item #2) Hardcover book, “The Emperor’s New Clothes” by Hans Christian Andersen and Illustrated by Susanna Davidson.
Item #3) Audio CD, Dmitri Shostakovich, String Quartet No. 8, background music for when you put two and two together and go mad realizing what an enormous hack you are.
Postage paid, arrival date: 12/25/2008.
Message/Comments: Merry Christmas, Camille!
December 11, 2008 at 3:19 pm
Message/Comments: Happy Holidays, Camille!
Come on Cyrano, there’s a war going on. Pull yourself together man.
December 11, 2008 at 4:11 pm
Don’t be too hard on yourself, curv… Montauk may be in the township of East Hampton, but it’s separate from the village of East Hampton, which is what I think most folks think of when they say “East Hampton”
December 11, 2008 at 4:19 pm
Thanks Glenn. I feel better about myself already.
December 11, 2008 at 4:55 pm
Comparing Palin’s speech patterns to a sax solo might be marginally more persuasive if Paglia knew how to spell bebop correctly.
Well, actually no, it wouldn’t. One defining characteristic of any decent jazz solo is that it makes some kind of sense.
December 11, 2008 at 5:03 pm
Clearly Paglia underestimates the power of Reason and Happy Talk. We Liberals will employ the most effective Happy Talk ever devised to defeat the terrorists. If everyone had her attitude, no one would even try Happy Talk. Which is sure to achieve victory. Don’t make us use Reason on you, terrorists.
December 11, 2008 at 5:52 pm
…if Paglia knew how to spell bebop correctly.
I was wondering about that. Is it one of those words that used to be hyphenated, like “to-day”?
It’s hard to keep up with the language these kids use to-day.
December 11, 2008 at 8:43 pm
Why yes, it did used to be hyphenated. I like to mess with people’s heads by using archaic hyphenations along with sticking together two words that were never hyphenated like highschool. Depends on my mood. Well, it’s more than CamiPag’s ever done playing with the English language.
December 11, 2008 at 10:21 pm
but in working with these governors
who again on the front lines
are forced to and it’s our privileged obligation
to find solutions to the challenges facing our own states
every day being held accountable
not being just one of many
just casting votes or voting present every once in a while
we don’t get away with that
That is Umar Bin Fvcking Hassan, daddy-o. Rock on wich yo’ own bad self.
Diddy!
December 11, 2008 at 10:35 pm
I think Camille is like the Ivy League’s Ann Coulter. Not having to have her Adam’s apple shaved every 6 weeks grants her a larger vocabulary. This lets her maintain a greater sense of patois, what horny pipestem huffers call Creole irony.
She raises a slightly finer rabble, and inspires us with a more satisfying tang of WTF???
December 12, 2008 at 7:52 am
kenmeer, that was a thing of beauty.
December 12, 2008 at 1:31 pm
yeah but shouldn’t that be piquant tang? Just sayin’.
December 12, 2008 at 1:53 pm
“yeah but shouldn’t that be piquant tang? Just sayin’.”
You are one of the few elitists who still remember that q is sometimes a form of silent double-s in Peron-era Argentinian Latin American Spanish.
Properly pronounced, it would be ‘pi-hant’, but so many vulgarians have added a pretentious un-silent ‘e’ after the word one can no longer tell piquant from taco sauce, much less pissant.
December 12, 2008 at 1:55 pm
I think we should accumulate half a dozen of the dear woman’s essays and do a Burroughsian cut-up opf them. Just to see if it makes any difference.
December 12, 2008 at 2:37 pm
One must use Christmas to fight Christmas, curv3ball. Jesus Christ himself understood this.
December 12, 2008 at 2:52 pm
maybe it’s time to turn my spam poetry blog (which has sort of morphed into a wingnut poetry blog…see exhibit a: http://eucheuch.wordpress.com/2008/12/08/civil-unrest/) into a palin poetry blog! what do you think MY FRIENDS?
December 12, 2008 at 3:33 pm
Hey Carlos Alazraqui is a homey of mine, bro. Of course we know our Arhyentinian spirants.
And no, there has got to be some sort of Palin/Paglia/Dada ergodic theorem, or maybe superLie operator formalism, where the one and the other are interchangeable/indistinguishable dynamically and/or if you look at each of them squint-eyed and through both ends of the intertube.
December 12, 2008 at 3:46 pm
KL, there’s an online cut-up engine at
http://vispo.com/cgi-bin/wonder/cutup/cutup.cgi
So I took six of Paglia’s salon.com articles and used them as input. The resulting text was generated using fragments sized between five and seven words. I lightly touched it up for grammatical reasons (which I believe is allowed within the Burroughsian tradition). It is this:
I repeatedly said that the politician who’s caught by the camera be breaking down those barriers. Feminism, terrorism against innocent American citizens and both zones — nice to visit but anyone, anywhere and under any sponsorship. Nice has enormous impact. Standing in the uncertainty.
Hence my unhappy surprise that I had never seen “The Scarlet” with her deep knowledge of short-fused character, whose rampant egotism made a hectic season. All year long, in the Democratic Party, which has worsened the right to vote after the Civil War sleep. In my first book, “Sexual Personae,” she has the basic managerial ability to name most notorious names of our more radical selves. Marriage may be a desirable kind of experimentation with standard English — we suffer another year of this?
About to emerge from the long sleep is a woman profoundly patriotic, as we’re g’s like there’s no tomorrow. It was the electrifying summation of Fitzgerald, and had been mayor of Boston. Power grid and complex transportation system, Dusty Springfield tamping herself down, then drops dead, a President recognition in an ephemeral beauty contest.
For many others, listening to Sarah films was their sexual candor. The professional world come near this level; their political mobility over future years (which I’ve never shared) may indeed never meet an elderly person like Poe’s baleful raven: people be-bop saxophonist.
I stand on what may rake in millions but won’t maliciously destroy their proponents. And it throats of the prissy, victim-mongering, philistine feminist to find this anti-carol on Nickelodeon, physical — something not normally of maximum appeal in the general election. Like the overblown Valerie Plame case (which I suspect wishes to survive).
Three different personalities in the space of John F. Kennedy, but JFK had enough personal gigs for college. I feasted on foreign films on the national stage, ruggedly stumping (as it should be). Sarah Palin, given these rampant doubts, is the possibility I detest for having led McCain. She was always pugnacious but too often, equally short-lived.
To deal with all I am very concerned about, that priceless legacy of genius: Book Review’s music feature, where a lover of poetry (my Bill Clinton period) leaves the poor and weak, the foreign-policy world-view of liberal Democrats, and the Oscars — with their parched, stylist-honed dissident protest against the bourgeois proprieties.
I detest Cheney fabulous. But while Fey has nailed Palin’s come-on strong later, and Gov. Kathleen Sebelius of Kansas’s vitality, it borders on the asses from their elbows.
Liberal-on-Cheney treats him as uninterested as I was. It’s to be the determining factor in the middle of the night? No, she evidently leaves no room in her most extreme ideas. But I am convinced that incoherence or incompetence was solid, as press reports had the raucous bravura and taunting raillery. Heading toward the Beckett (10 years after Cavett had graduated from Obama) Hillary Clinton may be Belverio — “Let’s Be Civil: Marriage Isn’t Kubrick.” His pop antecedents with her over-the-top sermon and Obama would have instabilities and diminishments. For a young insular bastion of trailing in the polls, this merely reflects. I’ve watched Obama gracefully step up. I stood there, a truck abortion, which results in the heterodox views of the AIDS flights of faux gemutlichkeit. All that no-business “turning an event” highlighting Republican terrorism against innocent American citizens of Iraq isn’t getting us anywhere.
Letters may be shortened for space. His sarcastic sneer, his one facial mannerism — example: which intriguingly postulates the quasi-religiosity? Check on her to remind everyone again of tawdry, furtive, high-placed Democrats as well as one reason I live in the leafy. It became apparent that she was younger weeks ago (her aping of a date). But I must admit to being puzzled as a panelist discussing women and religion at college in the 1960s, my baby-boom bathed in blood. But will the exercise in nation building end? No, a sterile room or bleak landscape. What has been subjected to an atrocious trouble by a persistent soft-pedaling New York? I was to enjoy Sarah Palin’s performance the Lubavitcher rabbi, Gavriel Holtzberg, and his equals!
I am delighted with the jumps, breaks and rippling momentum the media and liberal elite are pulling out that tiresome middle-aged mom (in a fascinating book): Sarah Palin is like Annie Edie. I found this “diaporama” in the New York Times, which he laughingly ripped out of a journal. The way that abortion became without being in the least wedded? The waning of the art film has been uncle, who both instinctively stepped back away from national affiliation into unseemly haste.
Feinstein, with — I don’t think sex, podiums or move-through crowds — has been that tiresome middle-aged mom card. She seems to be merely the Theodore Roethke Centenary Conference. Their embrace of abortion is famous among other things. It results in their immobilized faces and simpering smirks, and hair on the way out to a tiny, squalid cell-40. The way stodgy, portly Al Gore (evidently of the gullible press, who were the believers, mainly Mormons) thought we’d premier modernists (from James Joyce, debate) suggested that he lacks “I was a child.” Audacity will prove to be electrified young people. And what transformed our political is no Hitler or the product of the rebellious 1960s. Wealth radically raises the standard Uniform and her painful neglect of the great light-saber duels.
Roads and bridges! What joy, meaningful glances and exploring (a quiet magnetism) that has been an advance copy, which arrived as brash ambassador from America’s pioneer state. Four of my grandparents were born Feinstein and have sent me small inwardness. The audio extra of her; that led in turn to…
December 12, 2008 at 3:56 pm
TL;DR
Wow, some of that was actually pretty good. I liked:
“Marriage may be a desirable kind of experimentation with standard English…”
“I stood there, a truck abortion, which results in the heterodox views of the AIDS flights of faux gemutlichkeit.”
“Audacity will prove to be electrified young people.”
And who could forget:
“Wealth radically raises the standard Uniform and her painful neglect of the great light-saber duels.”
Pamille Caglia, ladies and gentlemen.
December 12, 2008 at 6:19 pm
“I repeatedly said that the politician who’s caught by the camera be breaking down those barriers.”
An opening volley be (-) bopped across the bow of our tie! It’s like she got street cred and shit!
Whoo. This Burroughs is some heavy blingo. I’m hearing Dubya sing The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance !
December 12, 2008 at 6:22 pm
“Nice has enormous impact. Standing in the uncertainty.”
Be shrill my bleating fart! It’s like she’s channeling The SP for VP!
December 12, 2008 at 6:27 pm
“an elderly person like Poe’s baleful raven: people be-bop saxophonist”
The Self recognizes The Self.
I am having palpitations. I am giddy as a sea lion squeaking its armpit with a well-lubed fin. It is like fractal banal penetration! The Aleph unfolds in my swirling toilet wash!
Cal-gon Be Takin’ Me Away!
December 12, 2008 at 6:34 pm
“I feasted on foreign films on the national stage, ruggedly stumping (as it should be).”
Shakespeare! For all we not merely foreign films ruggedly stumping on the national stage! Nay, strumpet, say no more but Be Mine! and be-bop my lula!
My pipestem is chewed and droolish, ladies and gentlemen. She is my only true love and I am sworn to win her for my own. Anyone got some Rohypnol?
I wanna do this *right*.
December 12, 2008 at 6:40 pm
“Republican terrorism against innocent American citizens of Iraq isn’t getting us anywhere.”
Damn. That made sense, even sense I can agree with. I’ma dump the bitch.
December 12, 2008 at 6:48 pm
“And no, there has got to be some sort of Palin/Paglia/Dada ergodic theorem, or maybe superLie operator formalism, where the one and the other are interchangeable/indistinguishable dynamically and/or if you look at each of them squint-eyed and through both ends of the intertube.”
Congratulations. I believe you have written a sentence that cannot be deconstructed. You could run it through a Burroughsian shredder and it would still make more or less sense, more or less.
December 12, 2008 at 7:21 pm
But I must admit to being puzzled as a panelist discussing women and religion at college in the 1960s, my baby-boom bathed in blood.
This is fantastic. If you ever want to write a screenplay or a novel with a character who is completely gonzo nuts, Paglia-cut-up is your Rosetta Stone.
December 12, 2008 at 7:21 pm
Damn. That made sense, even sense I can agree with. I’ma dump the bitch.
Roads and bridges, man. Roads and bridges.
December 12, 2008 at 8:42 pm
Dr Octagon… good times
armed with seven rounds of space doo doo pistols…
December 13, 2008 at 10:05 am
I believe cyrano’s experiment has just proved our point. My baby-boom bathed in blood. . Fuck, that even has the aliteration. And shizzle.
Now, let us all pray:
“Four of my grandparents were born Feinstein and have sent me small inwardness.
Amen.
December 13, 2008 at 10:09 am
Are you Feinstein? You look Feinstein…
December 13, 2008 at 1:41 pm
Paglia and Palin.
It isn’t their incoherent self serving self entitled self promotion as the Liberal Media would have you believe, but their magic babeliciousness that makes real plummers wanna break into break dancing (masturbation isn’t allowed here at the camp).
December 14, 2008 at 7:51 am
I tried it myself, using a simple 7-word-string plan, and only one quick shuffle:
“However, Cavett’s piece on Sarah serial syntax-killer from Wasilla High, one who seems to have no first language, frayed syntax, bungled grammar and Palin, was insufferably supercilious. With
run-on sentences, he called her the dripping disdain; he sniffed at her.”
December 14, 2008 at 5:17 pm
“Beat poetry”? Was “Beat poetry” invoked to defend the governor now? Someone tell Diane DiPrima that her lifetime of sacrifice has been shape-shifted into a crutch for the lyrically incompetent.
December 15, 2008 at 8:35 am
As the owner of a house in Montauk, let me just say that Montauk is part of the Hamptons. True, it’s a quieter part than East Hampton, but…why is Southampton spelled as one word and East Hampton as two, anyway?
February 19, 2009 at 1:36 pm
[...] even Camile Paglia’s (non X-rated) fantasy of Sarah Palin. Behold, the era of street rapping steyelzzz at the [...]