Megan McCardle just invented a perpetual motion machine:
One cannot help but admire Nancy Pelosi’s skill as a legislator. But it’s also pretty worrying. Are we now in a world where there is absolutely no recourse to the tyranny of the majority? Republicans and other opponents of the bill did their job on this; they persuaded the country that they didn’t want this bill. And that mattered basically not at all. If you don’t find that terrifying, let me suggest that you are a Democrat who has not yet contemplated what Republicans might do under similar circumstances. Farewell, social security! Au revoir, Medicare! The reason entitlements are hard to repeal is that the Republicans care about getting re-elected. If they didn’t—if they were willing to undertake this sort of suicide mission—then the legislative lock-in you’re counting on wouldn’t exist.
So let me get this straight: the GOP – once elected to filibuster proof majorities in the Senate, while in control of the House and White House – will vote in lockstep to repeal Social Security and Medicare in a wildly unpopular political jonestown massacre.
After which, the Dems will run on re-instating Social Security and Medicare, winning landslide victories that sweep the GOP from office and, upon retaking Washington, will reinstate Social Security and Medicare. After which, the Dems will be voted out for…doing something unpopular…rinse, repeat?
Actually, I have a different notion: the GOP needs old people to continue as a viable Party. If you’ve seen the voting trends, Republican voters sure ain’t getting any younger. Recall, the GOP took up the standard as “Defenders of Medicare” in the recent HCR brouhaha in part as a cynical ploy to defeat HCR, but also as a reflection of the aging demographics of the GOP.
They are the Party of “Get the Mexilibersociagayomoslems off my lawn.” And the country’s population is definitely trending Mexilibersociagayomoslem. Or at least, the kids don’t mind the Mexilibersociagayomoslems as much as their parents did.
I blame MTV and bussing.
But if the GOP turns on its base of angry white old people, who will they have left?
So fear not my ever-so-sincere Concern Trolling friend, Republicans not caring about being re-elected isn’t such a bad thing, even if it takes one cycle to clear them out and trim their constituency to a rump of a rump broken off the dirty south.
To quote a noted master political strategist, “Bring it on.”
March 22, 2010 at 11:32 am
I love the smell of conservatives eating shit sandwiches!
March 22, 2010 at 11:36 am
I just wish it smelled more like victory.
March 22, 2010 at 1:47 pm
[!RimShot!]
Napalm feces, aka brown paper bag of shit set on fire on grumpy old man’s front porch.
Win!!!!
March 22, 2010 at 11:34 am
I blame MTV and bussing.
Definitely bussing, especially gay bussing.
March 23, 2010 at 6:04 am
Since to be ‘bussed’ i.e. to be placed onto a bud and transported therein, must, BY THE LAWS OF ENGLISH PRONUNCIATION/SPELLING, have a double consonant, otherwise it would have to be pronounced ‘byoozed’ = ‘bused’ just as in “abused” , whereas bussed is pronounced as in “bust” which is correct.
Similarly with “focussed”, npot ‘focused’ (folk used?, “hey focused white boy”), yet I see all manner of people abusing the RULES withal.
March 23, 2010 at 6:10 am
onto a bus, that is. Although the other alternative might be nice also.
March 22, 2010 at 11:35 am
Megan’s “Progressive” pose gets shakier by the day. Her stuff’s always been thinly veiled right wing propoganda dressed up in academic fluff to my mind. The majority yesterday was razor thin anyway, and the legal challenges are going forward as we speak. I’m sure we’ll be hearing nothing but HCR through November at least, so its a little premature yet to say that the majority “imposed their will” on anyone.
March 22, 2010 at 11:59 am
I find it curious how he says that Republicans “convinced” America that they didn’t want healthcare reform, as if it were a legislator’s job to convince it’s constituency of anything rather than carrying out their constituents’ will.
March 22, 2010 at 1:02 pm
Not to mention the claim itself is full of shit.
There were many progressives who didn’t like this HCR – myself included – who answered thus on surveys/polls.
But the questions asked were rarely: is this better than the status quo, or better than nothing.
March 22, 2010 at 1:50 pm
It is time, Neo. You must choose. Will you take the Red Pill, or this Blue Dog Turd?
March 22, 2010 at 1:53 pm
‘cuz there are times when turds from a blue dog are easier to swallow than what some fools call freely chosen reality.
Today’s Republicans, the only people in history to claim that plutocratic theocracy is the only naturally free choice.
At least we’re not having to fight another goddam Civil War.
March 22, 2010 at 12:58 pm
I’m not even sure why she thinks this is news. Of course the Republicans would repeal medicare and social security if they thought they could get away with it – don’t we all already know this?
March 22, 2010 at 1:40 pm
You look like me before I’ve had my coffee.
March 22, 2010 at 3:56 pm
Funny line heard on morning DJ comedy hour:
You know you’re an alcoholic when the coffee wakes up and smells you.
March 22, 2010 at 1:43 pm
The Republican party would repeal the Republican party if they thought they could get away with it. Just to show us all that no one’s the boss of them now.
see: ‘You can’t fire ME! I <QUIT!’
March 22, 2010 at 1:38 pm
“I blame MTV and bussing.”
Valid conclusion but let’s not forget the evils of the backs of cereal boxes.
(*ahem*, and stand back, this will be pretty awful) I saw the best minds of my generation turned into box tops…
March 22, 2010 at 1:41 pm
Megan McCardle, as a media slut, has been reduced to remakes of 2Girls1Cup, only now it’s 1Girl2Cups.
March 22, 2010 at 2:48 pm
AFAIAC – if the Repubs stamp their wittle feet and say they H8! H8! H8!!! something, anything, it must be good. In fact anything that makes them jump and shout is OK by me.
March 22, 2010 at 3:53 pm
“Republicans and other opponents of the bill did their job on this; they persuaded the country that they didn’t want this bill. ”
Incidentally, the ambiguity of who was persuaded they didn’t want this bill displays the writerly precision that journalists are trained to perform.
I figured she meant the Reps went on a major PR blitz to convince us that if they “stamp their wittle feet and say they H8! H8! H8!!! something”, by golly, they *mean it.
I think they were trying to change their image from the party of NO to the party of HATE.
March 22, 2010 at 6:12 pm
Republicans and other opponents of the bill did their job on this; they persuaded the country that they didn’t want this bill. And that mattered basically not at all.
If only The People had some way of knowing the Democrats would try and pass health care! Maybe we should engage candidates and The People in a kind of public spectacle which required their participation in some civic way which would denote their preference and would result potentially in a particular outcome. Those lousy Democrats with their stealth 70 years of support of universal health care.
If you don’t find that terrifying, let me suggest that you are a Democrat who has not yet contemplated what Republicans might do under similar circumstances.
As an amnesiac who was ALSO in a coma for 35 years until last week, I forget what I had for lunch, but even still a small part of me seems to sense this is a testable hypothesis — if there were only SOME kind way we could judge what “Democrats” did when “Republicans” (or, say, 5 Supreme Court Justices, hypothetically) passed or supported things that the public didn’t like.
Yes, I liked being a coma better. Why?
March 22, 2010 at 6:48 pm
Well, somebody’s got to say it:
Megan McCardle is fucking retarded.
Wow, that has a nice meter to it, does it not?
March 23, 2010 at 6:08 am
Megan McCardle is a fucking retardle. And a media slut-ski all the way … oh…
March 22, 2010 at 7:11 pm
Ahh, the rush of political power!
Beware the Ides of March (the vernal equinox)!
Beware overreach in all its forms! Your power has already begun to wane.
March 23, 2010 at 3:23 am
[...] Perpetual Change « The Poor Man Institute [...]
March 23, 2010 at 12:34 pm
Megan’s side loses = the tyranny of the majority
Megan’s side wins = the genius of democracy
(And it’s only because Republicans “care about getting re-elected” that they don’t do things that will prevent them from getting re-elected! If they were willing to be self-destructive, they would act in a completely different manner, she can assure you.)
March 29, 2010 at 6:16 pm
[...] vast amounts of money to people who don’t need it. Megan McArdle views the whole thing as a personal affront. Calm down. [...]
April 1, 2010 at 11:10 am
If you don’t find that terrifying, let me suggest that you are a Democrat who has not yet contemplated what Republicans might do under similar circumstances. Farewell, social security! Au revoir, Medicare!
Wait, I’m supposed to be terrified of the Republicans driving the Republican Party off of a fucking cliff, pouring gasoline on the wreckage and lighting it on fire, and then calling in a tactical nuclear strike on the ashes?
Pfft. Bluff called, asshole.